Does the colour of a beer tell you how strong it is?
No. The colour of a beer does not tell you how strong it is. Colour comes mainly from how heavily the malt was roasted, while strength depends on how much sugar the yeast turned into alcohol. A pale golden beer can be very strong, and a jet-black beer can be fairly light. The only reliable guide to strength is the ABV on the label.
It is natural to assume that dark beer is strong and heavy, and pale beer is light. This is one of the most common beer myths.
What determines colour?
Colour comes mostly from malt. When barley is kilned or roasted at higher temperatures, it turns from pale straw to amber, brown and finally black. Brewers measure colour on the EBC or SRM scale. Pilsner malt is very pale, caramel malts are amber to deep red, and roasted barley and black malts are near black. A small amount of dark malt can colour a whole batch of beer without adding much to its alcohol.
Colour can also be influenced by long boiling, the beer’s ingredients and, in some mass-produced beers, added caramel colouring.
What determines strength?
Strength depends on the amount of fermentable sugar in the wort and how much of it yeast converts into alcohol. More malt, or added sugars, in the mash gives yeast more to work with. This is why strong beers are made with more grain, not necessarily darker grain.
Examples that break the rule
- Dark and light: Irish dry stout is black but often only around 4% ABV.
- Pale and strong: a golden Belgian tripel can reach 8 to 9% ABV.
- Dark and strong: imperial stouts and doppelbocks are both dark and strong, but that is a coincidence of style, not a rule.
- Pale and mild: light lagers are pale and low in alcohol, which is where the myth comes from.
What colour does and does not tell you
- It hints at flavour: pale beers tend toward bready and grainy notes. Amber beers toward caramel and toast. Dark beers toward coffee, chocolate and roast.
- It does not tell you strength, bitterness, body or calories.
- It does not tell you the style. Dark lagers and pale ales both exist.
How to know how strong a beer is
Check the ABV on the label. For example, Medusa Premium Strong Beer is 5.9% ABV, whatever its colour in the glass. For help working out how much alcohol is in a bottle, our guide to bottle strength shows how to calculate it from the volume and ABV.
Final thoughts
Colour is a clue to the malt, not to the alcohol. To choose a beer by strength, read the label and not the glass.
Was this article helpful?
Thanks — noted.
Have a question we haven't covered?
Ask us directly and we will answer.